Experimenting -- It's How We Learn

Blue Mesa Sunset
One night we went up on a hillside near the Tsegi Overlook. A beautiful sunset was our reward.
I think we were all so surprised to see that the color of the mesa on the far side of Chinle was a brilliant cobalt blue.
For a while, now I've been experimenting with trying to get different sky and land effects when painting sunrises and sunsets. I had been really, really pleased with this painting I'm doing for the upcoming show at Segil Gallery which I called "Blue Mesa Sunset".
Then I took it in to my master class with David Gallup.
One of the most useful, essential parts of every class is when we all bring in work for critique. David always makes us share what we think about it... the parts we like best, what worked what didn't -- what we think might be changed. I think it has helped me to learn how to better evaluate my own work. It also helps me see what I don't see. -- And it helps me see in a different way.
When I started to tell David about this one, there wasn't much I didn't like about it. For the most part, David liked it too (especially the sky), but then he said those deadly words, "It looks like you painted it from a photograph." David doesn't like us to use photos. And when we do, he doesn't want us to "copy" photos... he'd much rather have us interpret -- make changes which make it a painterly painting.
Of course, once he said it, I realized that the painting did look like I painted it from a photo because my foreground was almost all black. I have often struggled with knowing that photos don't show color in the darks, but not really knowing how to deal with it -- especially when my mind tells me it WAS dark... so the value should be dark. Apparently I still haven't learned to deal with this.
Anyhow, I went back in to this painting when I returned home and tried to introduce color into the darks. I'm not even sure you can see what I did with it by comparing this photo of the original painting with the one on my website. Can you? I think it's better, but as I look at it again right now, I'm thinking I need to make all of the values lighter. I added color, but the values seem too dark SIGH.
My next post will deal with another canyon scene and a little study I did in the studio to help work out some issues before trying to paint the scene with a larger canvas. Because of what I just did on this one, I wanted to see if I could use a plein air sketch of a sunrise in the canyon, plus a few photos and some pictures of other artists' work ... influences to help me experiment and figure out how to make my painting work better.
....And if I lighten the values on this one -- Blue Mesa Sunset -- , I'll share it again.
About a year ago I read a book called "Steal Like An Artist" by Austin Kleon. In it he refers to all creatives and uses himself - a writer - as an example. He writes about the importance of influences -- many influences. A person who only has one influence is a copyist. A person who has many influences can take those parts of each influence which most attracts him or her and combine them in order to make their own original work. The ideas in that book really resonated with me. Although I saw some chatter on Facebook saying that it was awful to encourage "stealing other people's work", I don't really think that those people understood what he was trying to say. I'm reading his current book called "Show Your Work" and I am reminded of the importance of sharing what you are learning and what you know in order to "cement" your own understanding and to create yourself as an artist.
To that end, I thought I'd share some of the hurdles I am trying to overcome as I learn to paint scenes with low light and close values. I hope you enjoy reading about my experiments. I'd love to hear your thoughts too.

Comments
Leave a Comment