Blog


Tomales Bay

Tomales Bay 9x12 Oil on linen panel
Tomales Bay 9x12 Oil on linen panel

 

The California Art Club arranged a paint-out retreat at the Marconi Center in Tomales Bay.  CAC Artist member, Richard Lindenberg and several other artists from the club worked hard to help organize this wonderful event for all of us.  Seventy-five or so artists gathered together to laugh, paint, exchange ideas and simply have a wonderful time together.  - Thanks to all of you!

 

I had never visited Tomales Bay and it was a real joy to be able to spend time doing what I love doing in a beautiful part of the world.  After a surprisingly winding and topographically varied drive through San Francisco to San Rafael and then toward the coast to get to the Marconi Center, Sharon and I checked in and wandered around the center to explore spots for future painting spots and to chat with those who had arrived earlier.  It was late afternoon and although there were artists painting everywhere, neither of us wanted to do more than settle in and explore.

We had a fun both at dinner and afterwards.  The food itself throughout the weekend was exceptional...  as well as plentiful.  The fact that it was delicious was especially deadly and I had to make sure I didn't eat everything I would have liked to eat.

This painting "Tomales Bay", is a plein air piece done on Saturday morning.   We had been told that there were several "good spots" with parking further south toward the mouth of the bay where the river empties into the bay.  Sharon and I drove around a bit and then decided on the spot we had seen a bit earlier.   We pulled off the road and began to paint.    Both of us liked the beautiful bright orange rust and ocher colors of the wetland area against the other colors in the water.  After about one-half hour we were joined by five or six other artists.  It was interesting.  We were all looking at the exact scene and yet each of us approached it differently and each painting turned out differently.  

It was a pleasant morning.  After a bit we headed back to the Center to hike around and chat with the other artists who were gathered together.  This fourth day of our road trip was starting out to be another great day!


Comments

8 Responses to Tomales Bay

Hi Marion,

I like the idea of this piece, though the design has issues. Funny, it never seems to be our colors that go far astray (the background hill is outstanding), or the suggestion of textures (all of which are fine in this piece), but possibly as that's what we tend to focus most of our attention on in the painting, the details. We, as painters, spend far too much time on the piddly, nit-picky stuff and far too little time on the design of the painting. So, forgive me for what's coming...

You have an extreme diagonal line cutting the painting in half from upper left to lower right via the stream and the attached group of trees. In fact, if you squint down you'll actually see a complete arrow pointing out of the upper left corner.

The stream itself leads you directly out of the painting on the lower right hand corner. Had you bent the stream and exited out the bottom of the picture frame, you would have had a better design. Again, we are not in the business of copying the scene and the facts of the location. Change what needs to be changed before you put brush to canvas. That's what the value sketch is for, to work out the problems before you paint yourself into a corner (pun intended).

The block of trees themselves are a heavy weight that have no counter balance. A simple patch of dark ground area on the right hand side would have done the trick (no need for actual "things" like bushes, figures, etc.). Color alone could have done the job for you (think checkerboard). I would also take a good "bite" out of the tree mass to break it up a little (a couple of sky holes).

The mountain and the bay are the exact same size and shape, just in mirror to each other. Lose some of the width of the bay and flatten the shape so that it doesn't match the mountain.

Visually, things are correct as to "what" they are, but the design problems overshadow this. As I said, I like the idea of this piece. Try making a few sketches, correcting the above issues, and then make another one. If you solve the design problems in the sketch first, then you won't have to deal with them later on in the painting.

Good idea. Work on the design a bit.

You know, Russell, I totally agree with you. I knew this wasn't my finest painting.

It's interesting because when I first was blocking this painting in on site, I knew that diagonal canal thingie was a problem so I DID change it up just as you suggested. The only trouble was I just didn't like it that way. Also I couldn't get the painting to lay back (although I think it still has some of THAT problem). Anyway, I changed the canal back again before the end of the painting session and liked it a bit more.

There WAS a dark shadow across the foreground of the painting and I should perhaps of emphasized that more.....

Hadn't thought about weighing the tree mass against another dark on the lower right... hmmmmm. Also didn't notice the parity between the shapes of the farground mountains and Tomales Bay.... DARN... why do I always miss that??

Ah well... miles and miles and miles of paint!

Thanks again, Russell.

This was such an unusual place to paint. The colors and the composition posed some definite challenges. I would love to line up all the paintings that were done there that day. It would make for an interesting comparison. I will be posting mine soon on my blog.

Hi Marion,

In your answer to my first post you defined what the real problem was...

"...when I first was blocking this painting in on site..."

Notice, you didn't say that you were having problems creating a well designed value sketch. You didn't say that you made a dozen or more thumbnails and then picked this particular composition. I'm willing to wager another box of donuts that you don't make value sketches at all before you open up your paint box. Right?

As Frank Webb often says, "Failing to plan is planning to fail."

It seems that the valuable use of the value sketch has gone by the wayside these days. Why? Well, maybe because very few if any of today's painters can actually draw (the foundation for all painting). We are in such a hurry to squish paint around that we don' take the time, a mere 10 minutes, to plan the painting out first. If I can't solve the problems of the design in a quick 5 to 10 minute sketch, then it's for sure that I'll never solve them during a 2 hour painting session.

This is why our paintings fail. The issues in this painting could have been resolved in a couple of minutes with the sketch. First, you could have curved the stream inward towards the bottom of the frame, giving you a way into the painting that way. You could also have taken the stream off of the side of the frame, which would have helped to "flatten" the ground plane.

Note: it's the more vertical oriented diagonal line of the stream that makes this piece look a bit wonky. That, coupled with the high eye line, makes the piece "stand up" rather than lie flat.

The curved line of the stream isn't doing you any favors either as the only time you see "curves" in a stream or river is when you are looking down on them from a high angle (like reading a map). At eye level, a stream or river should have "zig-zag" edges, not curved edges. Curved edges, in this case, bend the ground plane down making the ground appear as if tilted.

The design problems are correctable, but you can't do them on the canvas while you are painting. At that point you are too fixated on the brush and the application of the medium. Make your design decisions on the sketch before you pick up that brush.

The 10 minutes you spend getting the sketch right will save you hours of frustration, and most importantly, you'll make better paintings because of them.

Russell, I used to try to do thumbnails but could never really determine which composition was the best. I'd have several different choices of thumbnails and yet really hadn't accomplished anything.

I DO do a three-value underpainting block in usually using umber. I have found that that is very useful and helps me decide whether I have a pleasing composition and is very easy to wipe out or add to before I start using color, etc. HOWEVER I know my friend, Sharon, who is a very successful artist almost always does the thumbnails.

I know that most people recommend using the value thumbnails so I may try again....

Thanks again.

Marion,

If you come up with 3 or 4 ideas, that's the whole point of sketches. And, you have accomplished a great deal. It's easier to refine or discard an idea at the thumbnail stage than it is to spend 3 hours on a painting, only to find out that the idea doesn't work.

For any one painting, I might do 5 to 10 sketches (sometimes more), before deciding on the right way to state my idea. The 30 minutes of sketching saves me from hours of frustration and also tells me exactly how to make the painting from start to finish. I never have to ask the question, "...now what?", when I paint. Everything I need to know is in the sketch.

Sketches save time, they are never a waste of time. Not doing them is where you lose.

You want to get better as a painter? Really good? Then do the value sketches. Every artist that has ever been or is great now does them. That's how professionals do the job right.

Trust me on this.

I do trust you, Russell. Thanks for all of the examples you sent as well. You may have realized by now that I need lots of time to absorb when learning. I also need lots of practice. I'll work on it and thanks again!! - Marian

A man, upon exiting the NY subway, spied a Beatnik playing on a set of bongo drums. The man asked the Beatnik, "How do you get to Carnegie Hall?" The Beatnik replied, "Practice, Daddy oh, practice."

I heard this story first from the painter John Pike, though I've heard it often since then. A little cliche by now, but none the less true.

I know of only two ways to get better as a painter. The first is to draw. BTW, learn to draw with a good, #8 Sable round and a bottle of Sumi ink on plain drawing paper. You'll learn more in six months than you would have in ten years with a pencil. It's easier too.

Drawing is the foundation for all art. Without a good understanding of the principles of drawing, you'll never really succeed as a painter. As Henry Fukuhara said, "If you can't draw, then you can't paint." Funny, this is the step that's usually skipped by the current lot of painters these days.

The second way to get better at painting, is really simple, PAINT! The more you do something, the better you get at it, provided you did step #1, learning to draw. The two go hand in hand.

The truth of the matter is that if you want to get really good fast, then follow Ed Whitney's advice and DRAW!

PS. I'm more than happy to help you along the way. Just let me know what you need.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post


Topics

Archives