California Art Club Annual Critique Session
Each year the California Art Club presents a very popular event - an anonymous critique session. This year, members who were interested were asked to submit one or two digital images (an improvement from past years requiring slides) for critique. Members and the public attend whether or not they submit images because the viewing and feedback serve as valuable learning tools for all of the attendees.
This year the panel included sculptor Béla Bácsi and painters Amy Sidrane, Joseph Mendez and Tony Pro. The event was held at the Autry Museum and was underwritten by Sennelier. I knew some of the panelists' work but not others, and I couldn't help thinking that to serve as a panelist requires some special empathy as well as a strong understanding of the principles of the craft.
I was happy to see many artists I have met at exhibitions, workshops and working en plein air. It was a good feeling of a community of learners.
Eighty works were discussed in about three hours. All were accorded respect by starting with what was good with the painting or piece of sculpture and then by making suggestions for improving it. Over and over I heard about values, warms and cool placement, encouragement to study certain masters, questions about focal points and composition and reminders to think about light and its source and what it does as a form turns. Over and over....... value, drawing, edges, composition. ----- It seems that there is really nothing new, it's just getting to the place where your mind and your hand seem to do what you think you know! VALUE, DRAWING, EDGES, COMPOSITION.
This time I did submit images... two. One, - a seascape received many compliments... made me feel really nice. There was also a suggestion by Joseph Mendez (who impressed me during the entire session to be very insightful and able to clearly and simply articulate artistic concepts) to work on the foreground cliff to see if I could avoid too many repeating shapes ... the vertical lines that the volcanic structure of the rock had. I will think about it and see if I can take the advice. The second was a figurative work of a cook. Mostly it, too, was thought to be a good painting, but Tony Pro felt that the overhead light source was a good strong source and that I should darken the eye sockets, under the chin and some other areas to emphasize the light source. He reminded all of us that it's ALWAYS ABOUT THE LIGHT.
The CAC hosts, Elaine and Peter Adams, polled the members and it was decided to do the critique sessions twice a year and to limit the number of images one participant can submit to one and the total number of images to 60. - Thanks, CAC for another good opportunity to learn.
Comments
3 Responses to California Art Club Annual Critique Session
Leave a Comment