Blog


Seeing As A Collector

Swirling Seas  24x24  O/C
Swirling Seas 24x24 O/C

 

Several years ago I bought the book, "'Starving' to Successful" by J. Jason Horejs.   I bought it, but like so many things in my life, as soon as I got it, I put it on a shelf and never got around to reading it through -- much less implementing any of the suggestions in the book.

Finally, due in major part to Horejs'  terrific email marketing campaign, I decided to read it and to include his suggestions in my action plan for continued improvement.  Of course, it turns out I've already been doing many of the things suggested.  That's great.  But I had been feeling like I had reached a stall and wanted to break out.

 

The initial chapter deals with QUALITY.  Quality is such an elusive and ever-moving target.  We are all familiar with having an artwork declined by one juror and go on to win a prize in another show juried by a different juror.   I do know I'm moving in the right direction though.  I can see that my work gets better every year.  But one suggestion in the chapter really caught my imagination.  I thought it was an excellent idea and have already started to implement it.

 

I am fortunate to receive fairly regular critiques of work that I take in to David Gallup's Master Class.  But Horejs' suggestion was a bit different than a critique of individual pieces.  His idea related to a body of work.

 

He first suggested we perform a self evaluation of 5-10 of our most recent works and ask ourselves "What are three things I could do to improve the quality of my work?"  -- To try to see our work as a collector would.  I then realized that much of my work is designed to please me....  It gets better all the time related to composition, value, brushwork, and color but perhaps I am too blind to see it the way a collector might. 

 

Then he suggested that we ask trusted advisers for a similar evaluation.  We should not ask what those advisers think of our work -- we should ask for three specific changes we could make to our work to improve the quality. 

 

I began trying this idea out yesterday and found that it is a very difficult task for someone to do.  After arranging for a meeting - a favor (to discuss my artwork) - and offering lunch as a way to smooth the way, I started out with this experiment.  I took in eight pieces of my recent work including "Swirling Seas".    All were landscapes / seascapes / skyscapes -- although some included figures.  Then I read the section of the book about quality to my adviser, who runs a gallery and who has known my work for many years now - even has some hanging there right now.  I got my notebook out ready to take notes.  That's when I realized that this is a VERY challenging task -- to go beyond critiquing individual work and to envision what it would take to improve overall quality of someone's body of work.

 

It was an interesting afternoon.   It was one that didn't have any great "ahas" but one which will help me continue on my journey to create paintings that are unique and powerful visions that will attract collectors.  

When I returned home and shared my afternoon with my husband, he felt that quality was not my problem.  He would like to see fewer landscapes and more "lively" subjects.  Perhaps genre is an issue, but it's the landscapes that I love, so I will continue to paint landscapes AND to continue to commit to a life-long pursuit of ever-higher quality.

I will also find other advisers, somehow, and try it again and then again.  It's probably something that all of us should be doing on a regular basis even though it turns out to be more difficult for the advisers than I had thought it would be!


Comments

9 Responses to Seeing As A Collector

Interesting. Do you think the discussion had any positive influence on you? Evaluating your work is a very intimate exchange that may need someone who is not afraid of hurting your feelings. Not something everyone is comfortable with. On the other hand maybe what you want to know is something that you need to internalize and realize for yourself.

Your sea and rock paintings have always been amongst my favorites, Marian. I do love when you add figures on the beach for that spark of life, but it is those seascapes that snag my heart every time. Quality is not a problem for you.

Hi Sharon,
Yes, I'd say overall it was a very positive experience, even though it wasn't what I had expected. It came a a great time and was useful.

I was hoping for more global ahas but I imagine if I do this more I will hear different things and set my mind off in different directions. We'll see won't we.

I love your pieces. Keep paintin'.

Thank you Sherry. I always appreciate your kind words.

TANYA!!!!!!!

So great to hear from you! I will keep painting as I'm sure you will too!

Your friend Ocie is coming out soon and hopefully we can get out to paint together like we did last time. Thanks for connecting us!

Be well.

Ts one thing to recognize a work that doesn't look professional, but it's quite difficult to pinpoint what it lacks . Many teachers who paint beautifully are often unable to articulate exactly where a painting fails. Personally I think skillful brushwork is often at the crux. Difficult to teach.


My comments were not directed to your paintings, marion, but generally on the subject of critiquing. Your joy of painting is evident in your work and that delight shines through and communicates to the viewer.

Hi Patty!
Thanks for dropping by the blog! It was such fun seeing you up in Santa Barbara on that First Thursday event!
You look great and seem to be enjoying your new location!

Regarding this type of critique... I think it is much easier to make suggestions about individual pieces and what the person critiquing thinks might make them better. The artist of course can use those suggestions - or not...

This idea, however, goes beyond finding places in individual pieces of artwork which might be changed... It's about direction.
Of course as you point out, it's up to the artist to decide his or her own course, but it is a good way to "see differently".

As a result of this post a good friend who has seen almost all of my work in the last year sent me a very thoughtful, honest note with a suggestion about where she felt I should direct my quest for improvement. Frankly I probably would never have taken my paintings to her for this purpose -- I just wouldn't have thought to do so -- but my guess is she has given me the most challenging and exciting (and probably impossible) direction AND one that I will take with enthusiasm and joy!

Be well and have a grand Thanksgiving!


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post


Topics

Archives